“I had opinions
That didn't matter”
--The White Stripes
The first live round has to be the Week
Of The Season for The Voice, doesn't it? Three full days of shows,
twenty singers performing live in a pair of two hour shows that, for
The Voice, are pretty filler-free. Carson starts looking concerned
around the hour mark and the stupid hashtag promo that is early in
the broadcast falls by the wayside as the judges give the most
useless positive propaganda feedback of the year and the clock tick
tick ticks until by the end, of course, it is a rushed blur. It's a
great time!
Whoever is doing the social media
promotions for NBC needs to rethink their career direction.
#Voiceboop. What the hell? Poking noses on video? The people that
are going to do this are people that frankly I don't want anything to
do with. At least Blake called it out for the nonsense it was. You
want a hashtag, NBC? #TSAVFL. You're welcome. Although now
that I think about it we need to get The Voice Fantasy League
trademarked in order to monetize this sucker once someone happens
upon it and tries to capitalize. We'll also need a spokesperson
because there is no way in hell that I am going to be seen on camera
in the Voice audience. Maybe Langdon? She could convince kids to
sign up for exclusive league access for the low price of $20/season.
USE YOUR PARENTS CARD, KIDS! We will all share in the TSAVFL bounty.
If cash is involved I might even ease up on the recap swearing,
though let's not get our hopes too high there.
That tangent reminds me to tell you a
couple of things upfront. First, this might be long, befitting the
Week Of The Season. Secondly, though you might think that life in
the Pierce/Hutchins household is a merry carousel filled with wit and
glamour, I am currently washing down the first two hours of a root
canal with pain meds and beer, and my lovely wife is occupied at this
very second with colonoscopy prep, so yeah, we are certainly living
the dream tonight. The point is just to note that there could be a
few tangents you'll have to forgive my indulgence of; and serves as a
reminder that truly there is little I'm not willing to share with
you.
To the shows! Let's take this by
coach.
There is a goddamn REASON that Blake
wins so many of these things. Cory Kent White. Grampa died. He's
getting marriage proposals via twitter (possibly not heartfelt).
Singing To Make You Feel My Love.
Explaning his complete marketing strategy to Cory first
thing in rehearsals. He uses
the funny drunk persona to Columbo the fact that he tells you exactly
what he is going to do and why it will work while he is doing it.
All I could think of was why the hell did I not pick him in
the bonus picks because OF
COURSE he is going to be in the finals.
I had
high hopes for Sarah Potenza though there were three strikes against
her: singing first on the first night. I've thought a lot this week
about what night and what order is optimum and though I've no
conclusion, first on Monday cannot be a good thing. Then, condensing
a song of epic scope and one where the slow build makes it so
powerful is a challenge – if there is ever a song that needs to
take its time and spread its wings it is Freebird.
You can't condense it without making it sound odd and rushed and
nowhere near as powerful. Finally, she slept in vans after eating
tuna fish for dinner. All I could do for the next few minutes was
imagine how nasty that van must have been.
Meghan
Linsey apparently has internet haters. I admit to wanting to look
but lately I'm trying to be better about not swimming in the more
toxic pools of our modern lives so am not going to. I don't like her
anyway, but that is because the desperation that surrounds her like a
halo makes me uncomfortable. Brooke Adee had a date, seems very
sweet, sang fine and showed that she needs some more training. And
then there's Hannah. Deb still hates her and laughed
when Hannah said that she'd never had a boyfriend. I've gotten
protective about her (remember, this is what happens with me) and I
felt sad for her. Her fragility just beneath the surface is a little
heartbreaking, and I felt that in her performance she was a little
embarrassed about being Crazy Eyes and was trying to tone it down a
bit – which is a mistake. Her ability to be fully uninhibited is
what makes her special.
I ranked all the
teams before the selections. My rank for Blake's team was (actual in
bold):
Cory,
Sarah, Hannah,
Brooke & Meghan.
I was most wrong here. I think that Blake has the shallowest team
because I cannot imagine Hannah & Meghan making say the top 8,
but he has Cory and Cory has a damn fine shot at winning this thing.
He certainly has the best coach.
Pharrell
had fantastic shirts
both nights. I would love either of those, though prints can be
problematic, cliché or both on big men. It is a mistake to read too
much into any filmed encounter but Pharrell seems genuinely impressed
by Sawyer Fredericks. How could you not? I think the only thing
that stops Sawyer in this competition is the fact that he is a
sheltered 15 year old boy who is all of a sudden getting LOTS of
attention. He reminds me a little bit of Kelly Leek from The
Bad News Bears.
Chris
Jamison looked good. I laughed when Carson asked “So, what are you
doing?”. I don't remember what he replied, but I figured the true
answer was, “Crushin'
it!”
Deb remembered his pants that he wore when he went sexy last season
and then I realized that I did too. I suspect Chris is having a
great year.
Anyway,
boy, does Mia Z. look strong or what? She looks tiny even by the
standard of tiny young women on The Voice, and she doesn't look to be
relaxed on camera and as such doesn't project a lot of personality to
me, but my god, she is sixteen.
They are so young. But all that fades away when the music starts
because I flat out love
listening to her sing. And Ain't
No Sunshine
is a great song. SHE WENT IN THE LAST ROUND PEOPLE. I think it is a
nice sleeper by Ed, who both got that pick and put her in his bonus.
Caitlin
Caporale looked more focused. Where she talked in her intro about
not chasing the career because she had no funds to move it came off
as putting aside, possibly for good, your dream. Getting to the live
rounds it was as if she wanted it again and had a sudden confidence.
I did not know the Beyonce' song, but thought she sang very well.
Koryn Hawthorne was so shaky at first, you could almost feel her
trembling through the screen but she killed the last half of How
Great Thou Art.
Lowell Oakley changed from his awkward improv last week but didn't
actually change that much and Pharrell was mostly done with him
anyway.
My
rank: Sawyer,
Mia,
Koryn/Caitlin,
Lowell. I felt bad for Caitlin but she is fourth in that group which
is a stronger one than I thought a couple weeks ago.
I took fewer notes on Tuesday's show, which again made me wonder
which night was the better to be on. At first I thought that Sia's
hat was odd and strange, but then I remembered that Daft Punk wears
helmets and what is the difference? It felt like a small evolution.
Xtina looked like Good Elvira on Monday and had a much better look on
Tuesday in that dress. I like that she has seemed more competitive
this year, and in the vein seemed to already have in mind the singers
she thought would go through. Clearly she likes India Carney by
giving her one of her songs, and she should because India Carney is
awesome and got the most bonus picks, six teams have her.
Have
to confess that when NBC promoed “A Song That Has Never Been
Licensed For The Voice Before!” I was expecting just a little bit
more than 4 Non Blondes. But once again Kimberly Nichole just killed
it and made a song I haven't even heard in twenty years sound vital.
I don't know that she can win but I know that whenever she goes out
it will seem a little bit unfair. Rob Taylor sang The Weeknd. Rob,
don't read blogs!! We are full of bad things for you to get in your
head right now.
You
may remember that I was rethinking my stance on Sonic, but luckily
she has a Twitter handle of @SonicArtOfBeing and once again reminded
me that she was deaf and so I was super happy to be able to reclaim
my dislike and jeer – but then Sonic got confused with the tempo
(I'm assuming because of the hearing problem) and I felt like such
an
asshole. Not disappointed that she is gone though. Lexi Davila
learned how unfortunate it is when the big note on your song doesn't
work. Twice.
My
rank: Kimberly,
India,
Rob,
Lexi, Sonic. Nailed it! This team could win or be down to one
quickly.
And
then, as always, there is Adam. You can imagine my dismay as I found
myself either agreeing with or approving decisions made by him, but I
could balance that out by how much I hated that song they played
first thing on Monday, Sugar.
Deb pointed out that we have that Maroon 5 song. My wife finds a
large amount of music and has an impressive track record, but it is
my considered opinion that Sugar
is a horrible thing. There were other things that didn't do much for
me on Adam's team. Nathan Hermida for example. It's not his fault,
he's just hit his limit in this lineup. Well, it's kind of his fault
because he wasn't good, though I liked the little rap he did in the
middle. But it was clear he overachieved to reach the live rounds.
I
enjoy Tonya Boyd-Cannon and thought she deserved the top three. It
was an interesting point that Adam brought up in rehearsal for Take
Me to the Pilot,
that it could be as close to gospel music that he (and I) got as a
kid growing up in a white suburb. She was first up as well. Brian
Johnson is also on my team so you'd think I'd pay attention but
instead Deb and I spoke of macarons as he sang. I also figured out
that he looks like a heavy Mr. Bean.
Who
got my attention was Deanna Johnson singing Down
to the River to Pray,
a song I know well. When I first saw her my thought was nice,
NBC. Put the nervous girl last.
She was stunning. There isn't anything else to even say except nice
bonus pick GAT and Deb's quote: “that dress is blowing my fucking
mind.” But I liked Joshua Davis even more (barely but still and
totally get if you have it the other way)! Deb's quote at the
beginning of his segment: “did you see that baby? That got him
10,000 votes right there.” I didn't know the song Budapest
but I liked it a ton and he was so good that when Deb asked me if we
should go listen to the original I said “Why? I like this
version.” (the original is good too but I'm not sure I like it
better than Joshua's version).
Christina had that sweet comment about him singing lullabys to his
kids and it was one of the most genuine sounding things I've heard
from her.
My
rank: Joshua,
Deanna,
Tonya, Brian,
Nathan. Another strong top two.
BUT WHAT ABOUT THE TSAVFL???
The
TSAVFL, my friends, is fascinating. We will start with a brief
moment of silence for our first casualty. The end of Sarah Potenza
spelled the end of Walla Walla Whoopemup. In an appreciated bid Tim
asked me if there were any points for going out first. Alas, there
are not. I am pouring out a 40 for him though I am pouring it into a
glass because after all this is The Voice and I'm not wasting good
beer. I thought with Cody and Sarah you would have gone further, but
y'know, many of my opinions are wrong.
The
one to beat currently is Hummingbird Lightfoot. Jim still has three
singers left though I think Deanna and Rob are his main threats. I
don't know what to think of Rob's chances. Barry
and the Ladies are close behind in the standings with two solid
singers, Kimberly and Mia. I love both of them so think they could
both be finalists but I didn't pick either of them as a bonus and
could
be isn't will
be. Debbie Eaglesong has what may be the strongest duo in Sawyer and
Cory. I will tell you right now that if she picks the actual winner
for the third straight year you will all hear about it. And Fluffy
Koalababy just might be making a comeback for the ages if Koryn and
Hannah can stay strong!
Karaoke SongBookWorms are down to one, but when that one is India
Carney there are still plenty of points to be had, especially if
bonus picks come through. Tied with Deb, Sizzle and Fizzle's hopes
now ride on one Joshua Davis who could easily be Josh Kaufman. He
could also be that singer/songwriter-y guy that flamed out last year
and whose name I can't remember. Champion Bull is no such thing
unless we are talking a different sort of bull because I am down to
Mr. Bean.
I've
said plenty but have one strategic maneuver to relate. Jim sent Deb
an email suggesting that she pick all her own team for her bonus
picks. At first Deb laughed it off but she kept coming back to it
occasionally and finally decided why
not!
Always eager to instigate, I sent an email to Jim:
By
the way, you successfully goaded Deb into picking her team for her
bonus picks, you magnificent bastard.
Jim replied:
Wow.
Her arrogance is admirable.
Indeed it is. And people, Jim is clearly a master manipulator.
Beware.
I have to say that I was pretty well floored with Adam's decision -- I did not expect that at all.
ReplyDeleteSawyer Fredericks... I didn't put him in my final three even though I really do like the way he sings. It does seem like his age is going to catch up with him and I feel that he doesn't make a strong physical connection. Every close up shot of him makes me feel like he's looking at something on top of my head. Yes, he's belting out whatever song he's seeing and doing an amazing job of it, but I still experience some of the Uncanny Valley with him.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley
Anyway, I agree that this is by far the most stressful week of the season. I wish we all still had 6 people continuing on... but somebody has to win and most people have to lose. That's life. Good luck!
Thanks for calling me a manipulator. Now no one will return my calls. Which is ideal, since I hate talking on the phone.
ReplyDeleteI feel kind of sorry for Hannah Kirbey, too. She painted herself into this awkward corner and now has to play the hippy-dancing-monkey role for the rest of the show. Her next song is What Condition My Condition Was In - The First Edition.
I have India Carney in my top 3, but her constant use of melisma is really irritating. If I only listen to her, it’s distracting. If I watch her, though, I think she’s great. Her eyes and movement on stage really add to the song. She could be The Voice’s Jennifer Hudson, who I don’t particularly listen to, but she has an Oscar. India should do I Want You - Elvis Costello.
Unlike India, Sawyer Fredricks is better if you can’t see him. His voice is amazing, but most of the time I see a scared little doll. Ed nailed the uncanny valley call. Song To The Siren - Tim Buckley would be great by Sawyer.
Cory Kent White bores me. Only Country singer left is about all anyone can say. I recognize his appeal, but elipsis ... Cory will do Jesus and Bocephus - Kid Rock because country.
Joshua Davis is handsome. His voice is handsome. He sings all the notes, but he is one-note, one-handsome-note. He should try South Central Rain - REM.
Rob Taylor is on my team. I want him to do well. Drayson’s sad butt comment has poisoned that well. Of course he should sing Chains Of Love - Erasure.
Everyone loves Deanna Johnson. She is also on my team, so I want her to do well. I don’t like her version of Down To The River, partly because she kept sating Down In The River. I appreciate her voice but don’t really like her version of any song I’ve heard her sing. I am being ungrateful. She should go with Wreck Of The Edmond Fitzgerald - Gordon Lightfoot, Hummingbird’s brother.
Brian Johnson has a really good voice. He seems super sincere. He reminds me a bit of one of my nephews. For that reason alone, he cannot win. But I want to hear him do Loving You Is Killing Me - Aloe Blacc before he goes.
Kimberly Nicole is a little too polished for me. She blind auditioned with Nutbush City limits which is my least favorite Tina Turner song. I can’t imagine her without a tutu. Sawyer and his ubiquitous hat, Kimberly and her tutu. I wish Lowell had only performed in a ski-mask. Kimberly sings the hell out of Thin Line Between Love And Hate - The Persuaders.
Megan Linsey scares me a little. When she gets voted off, someone’s getting hurt. She’ll do a great Since I Been Loving You - Led Zeppelin, though.
Why Mia Z? She creeps me out. She’s to young to be slinking around like that. She be able to hit one note in Loving You - Minnie Riperton. Why has she not done that yet.
Koryn Hawthorne is kind of awesome. I could listen to her sing I’m Pepping This Pizza all day. Koryn will rip into Bargain - The Who and make us forget who Roger Daltry is. Thank you, Koryn.
Jim, go work for The Voicw and make them use your song selections. I don't care who you have to screw and/or pay off to do it, do it NOW.
ReplyDeleteSorry for the loss to WWW’s team. I thought Miss Potenza could do some serious winning. I believe she was sacrificed for Hannah and that is just not fair.
ReplyDeleteMaybe instead of points for losing hardest, we can give an extra first or second draft choice placement. They do that in the NBA and it really encourages a race to the bottom.
Colonoscopies and root canals?!? Good lord! You NEED The Voice!
ReplyDeleteAm I lame to say this season is pretty awesome? As I'm sure you can imagine, I was jumping off of the couch and screaming with shocked delight numerous times. Only the Tonya stunner took me aback, but I can't really hate on Brian - he's just... awwwww. But I genuinely am impressed with, and don't even hate on, all 12 of the remaining singers.
Deb, we are going to THROW DOWN about Hannah! That's my girl! Well Koryn's my girl! They're both my GIRLS!!!
Deanna is a beautiful Amazonian elf spirit witchy woman.
Pat, you nailed it - Blake and the Columbo strategy! Ah, you nailed everything in your post!!
Tim - you won the new trophy!!! Think of it that way!!
Just so you know, Gina, had she moved on, I was going to have Sarah Potenza singing a rock version of To Love Somebody by the Bee Gees. She would kill it.
ReplyDeleteLowell Oakley would do Green Onions by Booker T and the MGs. He would be on stage, music playing, before he realized there were no words. He would begin improvising the lyrics. Really, truly offensive lyrics. Carson Daly would stop the song about half way through, and have him escorted from the building. Mia Z would boo him on the way out. The coaches would high 5.
YES
DeleteJim's world is soooo intriguing.
DeleteYour last part about Sarah Potenza I read as, "Tove Lo's 'Somebody by the Bee Gees'". I could not place that Tove Lo song. Now that I see my error, I wonder if Tove Lo is a stage name play on the words "To Love". Assuming we are taking about Daddy's at the playground, I think I am totally right. Otherwise, it's a Friday night after a long week.
Um... I apologize to Lowell.
ReplyDeleteI kind of don’t like him.
Love the comments, meant to jump in over the weekend but got distracted as usual and now I don't remember what I was going to say.
ReplyDeleteExcept that I am on board with assigning only instrumentals to Lowell Oakley.
Of all the singers still in the competition, Hannah is the only one who makes me grin like an idiot when she performs (sorry, Deb!!). Oh, and I watch the Voice while walking on the treadmill and I usually run when she's on (what?!!! I hate running!!) and I also don't look at how much time I have left to go (also rare!). So there's that.
ReplyDeleteShe just can't help herself - that's why I love her! It doesn't feel like a schtick. And she's just sings so dang good!
DeleteYou've inspired me - next time I watch the Voice, I'll do my back exercises!
Shoot, I thought if I typed that about exercising and posted it, I'd then feel shamed into doing it.
DeleteNope!!
I hashtagged yesterday... I did my part.
ReplyDelete